Soil Science Society of America Journal 64:1867-1876 (2000)
© 2000 Soil Science Society of America
DIVISION S-8-NUTRIENT MANAGEMENT & SOIL & PLANT ANALYSIS
Yields and Nitrogen Dynamics in a RiceWheat System Using Green Manure and Inorganic Fertilizer
Milkha S. Aulakha,
Tejinder S. Kheraa,
John W. Doranb,
Kuldip-Singhc and
Bijay-Singha
a Dep. of Soils, Punjab Agricultural Univ., Ludhiana 141004, Punjab, India
b USDA-ARS, East Campus, Univ. of Nebraska, Lincoln, NE 68583 USA
c Farm Advisory Service, Punjab Agricultural University, Kapurthala, Punjab, India
jdoran1{at}unl.edu
 |
ABSTRACT
|
|---|
Integrating fertilizer N (FN) with legume green manures (GM) can foster sustainable and environmentally sound agricultural systems in subtropical, semiarid soils low in organic matter. A 4-yr replicated field experiment with irrigated rice (Oryza sativa L.) and wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) rotations was conducted on a sandy loam soil in the Punjab of India to evaluate the effects of incorporating cowpea (Vigna unguiculata L.) or sesbania (Sesbania aculeata L.) GM on crop productivity, N-use efficiency, and NO3 leaching. Rice grain yields with pretransplant incorporation of 20 and 40 Mg GM ha-1 (GM20 and GM40) ranged from 5.18 to 5.81 Mg ha-1, which were equivalent to the 5.40 Mg ha-1 obtained with 120 kg FN ha-1 (FN120). Rice yield with 60 kg FN ha-1 (FN60) and GM20 was double the control yield and 6% greater than the FN120 treatment. Nitrogen utilization by rice was greater for GM20 than FN, as indicated by greater fertilizer N equivalents and an apparent N recovery by rice of 79 vs. 63%. While FN had no residual effects, residual GM produced greater wheat yields, indicating that FN applied to wheat could be reduced by 25%. Soil NO3N leaching to 60 cm in the rice crop was apparently used by the subsequent wheat crop, which has a deeper and more extensive rooting system. After 4 yr, use of FN120 for both crops resulted in 35 kg of residual NO3N ha-1 in the 150-cm soil profile (74% below 90 cm), whereas only 19 kg NO3N ha-1 remained with GM20 plus FN60. Use of GM20 with FN60 for a ricewheat rotation demonstrated greater yields of rice and wheat, 25 to 50% reduction in fertilizer N use, and decreased potential for groundwater NO3 contamination.
Abbreviations: ANR, apparent N recovery Db, bulk density FN, fertilizer N FN0, FN60, FN90, and FN120 represent 0, 60, 90, and 120 kg fertilizer N ha-1, respectively FNE, fertilizer N equivalent GM, legume green manure GM0, GM20, and GM40 represent 0, 20, and 40 Mg fresh weight green manure ha-1, respectively HI, harvest index OC, organic C RCBD, randomized complete block design
 |
INTRODUCTION
|
|---|
WHILE ONLY ONE-HALF of the 146 million ha under rice cultivation in the world is irrigated, it represents
75% of total rice production (IRRI, 1991). In Asia, irrigated rice is often a part of annual double cropping systems where upland crops such as wheat, maize (Zea mays L.), vegetables, or legumes follow rice, with ricewheat as the major cropping system. Production of rice and wheat has responded to N rates up to 120 kg N ha-1 on these subtropical, semiarid soils (Maskina et al., 1988), which are inherently low in organic matter and N levels.
In recent years, fertilizer cost and concern for sustainable soil productivity and ecological stability in relation to chemical fertilizer use have emerged as important issues (Aulakh and Pasricha, 1997a; Aulakh and Bijay-Singh, 1997). There is a renewed interest in organic manures, such as farmyard manures, composts, and green manures, as sources of plant nutrients (Yadvinder-Singh et al., 1988; Aulakh, 1994). Farmyard manures and composts are in limited supply and may have low and variable nutrient contents. The more readily available green manures constitute a valuable source of both N and organic matter (Buresh and De Datta, 1991; Ladha and Garrity, 1994; Ladha et al., 1996; Bijay-Singh and Yadvinder-Singh, 1997; Aulakh and Pasricha, 1997b).
In a ricewheat system, green manure crops such as cowpea and sesbania can be grown for 45 to 60 d in May and June when fields are fallow after the harvest of wheat. The green plants are incorporated into the soil in the third or fourth week of June prior to the transplanting of rice. Rice is grown during the monsoon season from July to October and wheat in winter from November to April. Information on benefits of integrating FN with legume GM or its use as an alternative source of nutrients will contribute greatly to development of sustainable agricultural management systems in semiarid, subtropical regions.
Nitrogen movement below the root zone and into the groundwater (Olson et al., 1970; Spalding and Kitchen, 1988) can cause human and animal health problems (USEPA, 1985). Leaching losses of N mainly occur as NO3, while leaching of NH4 is only a problem when applied in very large quantities on coarse-textured soils. Recent reviews (Aulakh, 1994; Bijay-Singh et al., 1995; Aulakh and Bijay-Singh, 1997) have revealed few studies on NO3 leaching in intensively cultivated semiarid, subtropical or tropical soils and no reports have addressed rice wheat cropping systems. In most of these studies, the distribution of NO3 in the soil profile has been determined at the end of different field experiments. No studies are available that report changes in NO3 and NH4, during and after the harvest of each crop grown in a rotation, occurring under dry and flooded cycles, application of FN, and the incorporation of GM or crop residues.
Traditional flooded paddy soils are fine textured with very low percolation rates. Upon flooding, these soils become anaerobic and nitrification is severely reduced, resulting in the continuous accumulation of NH4N. However, with increasing food and fiber demands to support growing populations as well as the creation of additional canal and tubewell water irrigation facilities, coarse-textured highly porous soils of subtropical regions are now used for raising both upland crops as well as wetland rice (Aulakh and Bijay-Singh, 1997; Aulakh and Pasricha, 1997b). In porous soils under rice, continuous flooding cannot be maintained due to high water percolation rates. Thus the porous soils exhibit alternate aerobic and anaerobic conditions and can support nitrification (Aulakh et al., 1996). Nitrate enrichment of groundwater beneath several irrigated porous soils is evident from the NO3 analysis of tubewell waters (Bajwa et al., 1993); however, no data have been reported on the effects of N fertilization and green manure crops on the dynamics of NO3 and NH4 in porous irrigated soils. Such studies would become more important as porous soils are increasingly used for irrigated ricewheat cropping systems.
A 4-yr field study with an irrigated ricewheat cropping system in a subtropical, semiarid porous soil was undertaken to investigate (i) the individual and combined effects of GM and FN on the yield response and N-use efficiency of irrigated rice, (ii) the capacity of GM to substitute for FN and its residual effect on the succeeding wheat crop, and (iii) N dynamics in soil during and after the harvest of rice and wheat crops, including the mineralization of GM-N and the amounts of NO3N and NH4N in the soil profile and the potential for their leaching below the rooting zone.
 |
Materials and methods
|
|---|
A 4-yr field experiment was conducted during 1992 to 1996 on a semiarid irrigated Tolewal sandy loam (Typic Ustochrept) soil at Punjab Agricultural University Research Farm, Ludhiana, India. Ludhiana is located 30° 54' N and 75° 48' E and is 247 m above mean sea level. The mean monthly minimum air temperatures during the 4 yr of the study ranged from 5 to 8° in January to 26 to 27°C in June, while maximum temperatures ranged from 8 to 19°C in January to 35 to 40°C in June. The annual rainfall ranged from 593 to 1227 mm, with 74 to 85% occurring from July to September. Characteristics of the Tolewal sandy loam soil (Table 1)
were determined by standard methods (Westerman, 1990). The plow layer (015 cm) had total N content of 0.4 g kg-1. The infiltration rate of the unpuddled soil averaged 1.0 cm h-1, and the puddled soil rate was 0.2 cm h-1. The groundwater table was below 8 m.
Treatments for wetland rice included three levels of FN (0, 60, and 120 kg N ha-1) and three levels of GM (0, 20, and 40 Mg fresh biomass ha-1) that were arranged in a randomized complete block design (RCBD) with three replications. Total numbers of treatment combinations were seven in Year 1, nine in Year 2, and 10 in Years 3 and 4 (Table 2)
. In Year 1, GM rates of 25 and 50 Mg ha-1 were incorporated instead of 20 and 40 Mg ha-1. For the sake of simplicity, these are referred to as 20 and 40 Mg GM ha-1 throughout the text.
Cowpea in Year 1 and sesbania in the following 3 yr were seeded as green manure crops in the fourth week of April or first week of May in GM plots. After irrigation, cowpea or sesbania seed was drilled in rows 20 cm apart at the rate of 50 kg ha-1 in near field capacity soil moisture. After 50 to 53 d, the GM crop was harvested and an appropriate amount of fresh biomass of GM (20 or 40 Mg ha-1) was uniformly distributed in respective treatment plots and incorporated into the soil in June, 2 d before transplanting rice plants.
Rice (cv. PR 106) was seeded in a separate field adjoining the experimental plots in the second week of May and fertilized with 15 kg N ha-1 and 17.5 kg P ha-1 as diammonium phosphate, and 10 kg zinc sulfate ha-1. Two weeks later, 25 kg N ha-1 as urea was top-dressed prior to irrigation. Healthy 45-d-old plants were transplanted two plants per hill in the third or fourth week of June. Rows were 20 cm apart with an in-row spacing of 15 cm, and the individual plots measured 3 by 10 m. Fertilizer N as urea was applied in three equal amounts at
0, 3, and 6 wk after transplanting. The experimental area was bordered with 10 rows of nonexperimental rice plants on all sides of the field. The crop was irrigated on a daily basis during the first month and thereafter on an as-needed basis at intervals to prevent a dry spell (soil surface without overlying water) of more than 2 d. This is a recommended practice of intermittent submergence for rice as it saves water but does not reduce rice yields (Sandhu et al., 1980). Irrigation water was used either from canal or tubewell and contained nominal N (<0.5 mg L-1). At maturity, the rice crop was harvested in the first or second week of October. Grain and straw yields were recorded and grain data are expressed on the basis of 140 g water kg-1 dry matter (14%).
Wheat (cv. HD 2329) was drilled at 40 kg seed ha-1 in early November in the same permanent plots as rice in rows 20 cm apart. A uniform application of 26.2 kg P ha-1 as single superphosphate was drilled in all plots at the time of seeding. Four rates of FN (0, 60, 90, or 120 kg N ha-1) as urea were broadcast in two equal splits, at seeding and 4 to 5 wk later (1 d after first irrigation). Thereafter irrigation was applied when required to maintain adequate moisture conditions (>50% of plant-available soil water). The middle 15 m2 of each plot was harvested in the second or third week of April. Grain and straw yields were recorded and the data are expressed on a dry weight basis. Aboveground crop residues except stubbles of both crops were removed from the plots. Concentration of N in grain and straw samples of both rice and wheat was determined by the micro-Kjeldahl method (Westerman, 1990).
Of the 10 different treatment combinations (Table 2), five were selected for monitoring the dynamics of NO3N and NH4N. These were GM0 FN0 (Rice)FN0 (Wheat), GM0 FN120FN120, GM20 FN0FN0, GM20 FN60FN90, and GM40 FN120FN90. Four cores were collected with a 5-cm-i.d. tube auger and composited separately for six soil depths (015, 1530, 3060, 6090, 90120, and 120150 cm) in 15 plots (5 treatments x 3 replications) at initiation and completion of the 4-yr study. Following the same protocol, soil samples were periodically taken from the upper three soil depths (015, 1530, and 3060 cm) before and/or after important field operations during three cycles of the ricewheat rotation to monitor the dynamics of NH4N and NO3N during and after each crop.
Field moist soil samples were thoroughly mixed, and representative subsamples were extracted immediately by shaking with 2 M KCl solution (1:6 soil/solution ratio) for 1 h on a mechanical shaker followed by filtration. The extracts were analyzed for NH4N and (NO3 + NO2)-N by a micro-Kjeldahl procedure (Mulvaney, 1996).
Bulk density (Db) of the soils was determined to a 150-cm depth with 5 cm i.d. by 15 cm long steel cores with open ends following the soil sampling protocol mentioned above for N dynamics. Bulk density measurements were made periodically during the 4 yr of the experiment, and mean Db values for five selected treatments were used for converting NH4N and NO3N concentrations (mg N kg-1 soil) to units of kg N ha-1.
Statistical analysis of experimental data was accomplished by standard analysis of variance (ANOVA) in RCBD (Gomez and Gomez, 1976) using IRRISTAT software (Bartolome et al., 1999). As three of the 10 treatments were not included in Year 1, only data from Years 2, 3, and 4 for rice and wheat yields, N uptake and recovery, and harvest index (HI) were used for repeated-measure pooled analysis. The data for the GM0 FN120FN90 treatment were not included for 3-yr pooled analysis as this treatment was missing in Year 2 (Table 2). Using a paired t test, no-N control (GM0 FN0FN0) and FN (GM0 FN120FN120) or control (GM0 FN0FN0) and GM (GM20 FN0FN0) treatments were compared for the data on NH4N and NO3N concentrations in the soil profile during rice and wheat crops. Harvest index of rice and wheat was calculated from the ratio grain yield/total yield (grain + straw). The fertilizer N equivalent (FNE) of GM in wetland rice is the quantity of FN that must be applied to obtain grain yield equal to that obtained with GM alone and was calculated following the procedure of Bouldin et al. (1984) and Yadvinder-Singh et al. (1995). First, from rice yield data obtained with different FN rates, the best-fit regression was searched using the scatter diagram technique and greatest R2 values (Gomez and Gomez, 1976). Then quadratic regression equation y = ax2 + bx + c was computed separately for each year using the regression module of IRRISTAT software (Bartolome et al., 1999). Where y is rice grain yield (Mg ha-1) obtained with FN, x is applied FN (kg ha-1), a and b are constants, and c is an intercept. Thereafter, FNE of GM was calculated by solving the x as follows
 | (1) |
Where y is the yield data obtained with the GM20 or GM40 rate. The same procedure was followed for computing FNE of GM using N uptake data.
Apparent N recovery (ANR) was calculated as follows
 |
Results and discussion
|
|---|
Rice Yield
Grain yield of rice was significantly greater in the plots treated with 120 kg FN ha-1 (GM0 FN120) than in the no-N control (GM0 FN0) plots (5.40 vs. 2.71 Mg ha-1). Three-year pooled analysis of rice yields for Years 2 to 4 revealed that rice yields and N responses did not differ significantly between years (Table 3) .
View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Table 3 Three-year (Years 24) mean rice grain and straw yield and total N uptake (grain + straw) as influenced by applied fertilizer N (FN) with and without green manure (GM)
|
|
Incorporation of 20 Mg GM ha-1 without FN (GM20 FN0), which added from 77 to 128 kg N ha-1 in the aboveground material (Table 4) , produced 91% greater grain yield than the no-N control on average across 3 yr (Table 3). Combined application of FN and GM showed a significant synergistic effect on rice grain yield in all years. Three-year mean rice grain yields for 60 kg FN ha-1 (GM0 FN60) and 120 kg FN ha-1 (GM0 FN120) were 58 and 99% greater than the unfertilized control. The yields for GM20 FN60, GM20 FN120, GM40 FN60, and GM40 FN120 were 2.13 to 3.03 Mg ha-1 greater than the control. Rice yield response to GM20 was greatest when applied with FN60, which yielded 8 to 17% more than the GM0 FN120 treatment, indicating that GM20 was more effective than FN60 in enhancing rice yield. The response to green manuring did not increase further when GM20 was applied in conjunction with FN120. With GM40 FN120, yield was significantly lower than with GM0 FN120. This may have been due to an excessive supply of N that produced excessive vegetative growth, as indicated by the high straw yield and decrease in HI from 0.44 to 0.39 (Table 3). This shift to greater early vegetative growth resulted in lodging of the crop and perhaps was the cause for reduction in rice grain yield.
Fertilizer Nitrogen Equivalence of Green Manure and Substitution of Nitrogen
Based on rice grain yields, the 3-yr mean FNE values of GM were 104 kg N ha-1 for the 20 Mg ha-1 rate and 138 kg N ha-1 for the 40 Mg ha-1 rate. This FNE value for GM20 corresponded with 24% greater than the total amount of N added through 20 Mg GM ha-1 (Table 4). The 3-yr mean FNE values estimated from N uptake values were 113 kg N ha-1 for the 20 Mg ha-1 rate and 179 kg N ha-1 for the 40 Mg ha-1 rate. These FNEs were substantially greater than those obtained from rice grain yield, as N uptake data also included N used by rice straw. For example, the very high rice straw yield of 7.59 Mg ha-1 obtained with 40 Mg GM ha-1 and the associated N uptake of 146 kg ha-1 (Table 3) reflected the relatively high mean FNE value of 179 kg N ha-1. These results suggest that the GM-N applied at 20 Mg ha-1 rate was better than FN in obtaining rice yields. The crop response to GM20 FN60 resulted in an additional increase in rice grain yield that was higher than with GM0 FN120, which is the optimum N rate for rice (Gill, 1995). This suggests that GM20 may enhance yield potential above that of FN alone, indicating a benefit of green manure beyond N supply. Possible explanations for this enhanced yield potential may include more favorable physical, chemical, and biological conditions, and nutrient availability in soils amended with GM (Yadvinder-Singh et al., 1988; Walters et al., 1992; Aulakh, 1994).
The narrow C/N ratio of GM (Table 4) resulted in rapid mineralization and allowed the GM to serve as an efficient source of N. This was reported earlier (Yadvinder-Singh et al., 1988; Aulakh et al., 1991) and was confirmed in a recent laboratory incubation study, where Khera et al. (1999) observed 36% mineralization of sesbania GM-N within 15 d. Efficient use of GM-N may be due to the synchrony between N release from incorporated GMs and crop plant N demand. Also, unlike FN, GM-N is less prone to losses through leaching of NO3 beyond the rooting zone (see below).
Residual Effects of Green Manure on Wheat
Fertilizer N applied to wetland rice in subtropical, semiarid soils often has no residual effect on succeeding crops (Maskina et al., 1988), and a fresh application of 120 kg FN ha-1 is recommended for wheat that follows wetland rice (Gill, 1995). However, information on the residual effects of green manures in ricewheat systems is not available. In our study, the 3-yr mean wheat grain yield of 2.24 Mg ha-1 without FN and GM (GM0 FN0FN0) increased to 4.53 Mg ha-1 with the GM0 FN120FN120 treatment (Table 5)
. Green manuring of rice exhibited a significant residual effect on the grain yield of wheat. Mean 3-yr yields of wheat increased 15% due to the residual effect of 20 Mg GM ha-1 (GM20 FN0FN0) applied to the preceding rice crop and 22% following 40 Mg GM ha-1 (GM40 FN0FN0). However, application of 120 kg FN ha-1 to wheat in plots not amended with GM (GM0 FN120FN120) and 90 kg FN ha-1 to wheat in GM20-amended plots (GM20 FN120FN90) resulted in statistically equivalent wheat grain yields and N uptake (Table 5). These results suggest that the use of green manuring in a ricewheat system may provide a similar effect as the application of 30 kg FN ha-1 to the following wheat crop and thus reduce its fertilizer N requirement by
25%.
View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Table 5 Three-year (Years 24) mean wheat grain and straw yield and total N uptake (grain + straw) as influenced by applied fertilizer N (FN) with and without residual green manure (GM)
|
|
Removal and Recovery of Nitrogen by Rice and Wheat
Nitrogen uptake by rice was significantly increased by the application of FN and GM (Table 3). Mean 3-yr total N uptake by rice grain and straw was 47 kg ha-1 in the control (FN0), 84 kg ha-1 in FN60, 123 kg ha-1 in FN120, 114 kg ha-1 in GM20 and 146 kg ha-1 in the GM40 treatments. Mean 3-yr ANR from FN60 and FN120 by rice was 62 and 63%, whereas for the GM20 and GM40 treatment, ANR was 79 and 59% (Table 6)
. Greater ANR of GM-N by rice at the GM20 rate than from the FN120 rate (79 vs. 63%) further illustrates the better utilization of N applied as GM. However, at the 40 Mg ha-1 application rate, recovery of N from GM decreased to 59%, perhaps due to a decrease in N-use efficiency by rice resulting from N in excess of crop needs for optimum yield (Morris et al., 1989).
Three-year mean total N uptake by wheat grain and straw was 37 kg ha-1 in the control, 66 kg ha-1 in FN60, and 105 kg ha-1 in FN120 treatments (Table 5). The N uptake with residual GM20 was 47 kg ha-1 and GM40 was 53 kg ha-1. The 3-yr mean ANR by wheat for the FN60 and FN120 treatments was 53 and 57% (Table 6). Three-year mean recovery of residual GM-N by wheat for the GM20 rate was 11% and GM40 rate was 16%. The increase in wheat yield due to the supply of N by residual GM was supported by soil mineral N data discussed below.
Dynamics of Ammonium and Nitrate in Soil
In general, the amount of NH4N and NO3N in the soil showed significant increases after application of urea to rice or wheat during different years. For example, Year 2 data for one ricewheat cycle presented in Fig. 1
illustrate that early-season rises in the amount of NH4N, and NO3N were generally greatest in the surface layer (015 cm) and less prominent in the 15- to 30- and 30- to 60-cm layers. Nevertheless, rapid distribution of applied FN to lower soil depths in this irrigated porous soil was evident. In all layers, the amount of NH4N or NO3N differed significantly between no-N (GM0 FN0FN0) and fertilizer N (GM0 FN120FN120) treatments according to paired t tests.

View larger version (29K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 1 Dynamics of (a) NH4N and (b) NO3N in three soil layers of no-N control (GM0 FN0FN0) and fertilizer N (GM0 FN120FN120) treatment in a ricewheat cropping system during Year 2 (19931994). GM is green manure and FN is fertilizer N; subscripts denote application rates (Mg ha-1 and kg ha-1, respectively). Arrows denote fertilizer N application. * Indicates significant difference (P 0.05) between no-N control and fertilizer N treatment. The periods under fallowing (F), rice, and wheat are marked on the x axis
|
|
It should be noted that the greater amount of NH4N and NO3N in the 30- to 60-cm layer was due to its greater thickness (and hence soil mass) than the 0- to 15- and 15- to 30-cm layers. Increases in mineral N [(NH4 + NO3)-N] in the 0- to 15-, 15- to 30- and 30- to 60-cm soil layers after fertilizer application were often similar to the amount of N applied. For instance, the 23 June 1993 sample date, which occurred 2 d after the application of 40 kg FN ha-1 (1/3 split dose) to rice, resulted in an increase of 39 kg NH4N and 9 kg NO3N ha-1 in the soil profile of the GM0 FN120FN120 treatment more than that of the GM0 FN0FN0 control (Fig. 1). Similarly, a basal application of 60 kg FN ha-1 (1/2 split dose) to wheat on 6 Nov. 1993 resulted in an increase of 16 kg NH4N and 36 kg NO3N ha-1 when sampled 5 d later on 11 Nov. 1993 (Fig. 1). The distribution of applied FN in the 0- to 60-cm soil depth within 1 to 5 d was followed by a decrease in mineral N concentrations, probably due to crop uptake or denitrification losses (Aulakh et al., 1992). However, these data suggest that mineral N determination in irrigated porous soils is most reliable when soil is sampled to a 60-cm depth instead of the current practice of only sampling to 15- or 30-cm depths (Anonymous, 1990).
After each FN application to the rice crop (JuneAugust), NH4N usually exceeded NO3N (Fig. 1), presumably due to reduced nitrification in the partially anaerobic soil systems that resulted from frequent irrigations. However, increased levels of NO3N in soil were frequently observed 1 to 5 d after each FN application. During the period of upland wheat growth (Novemberearly April), the amount of NO3N increased rapidly after FN application (Fig. 1b). These results confirmed findings of earlier controlled-environment studies that nitrification of applied ammoniacal N in subtropical near neutral soils is very rapid under aerobic conditions (Kuldip-Singh et al., 1996) and that such porous soils under partially anaerobic condition can support substantial nitrification of applied ammoniacal N (Aulakh et al., 1996).
Mineralization of Green Manure Nitrogen and Soil Organic Nitrogen during Fallow
Incorporation of fresh GM 2 d prior to transplanting rice was associated with rapid accumulation of mineral N in soil, mostly as NH4N, for 1 to 2 wk, followed by a slow decline during a 2- to 3-wk period (Fig. 2)
. Rapid mineralization of GM-N was supported by the accumulation of 103 kg mineral N (NH4 + NO3) ha-1 on 23 June 1993 (5 d after GM incorporation) in the GM20 treatment, as compared with 56 kg N ha-1 for the GM0 soil in Year 2 (Fig. 2). Similar results occurred in Year 3 with accumulation of 106 kg mineral N ha-1 on 28 June 1994 (14 d after GM incorporation), as compared with 76 kg N ha-1 in GM0 treatments (data not shown). As mentioned above, Khera et al. (1999) measured 36% mineralization of sesbania GM-N within 15 d in growth chamber studies conducted at 35°C. The rapid mineralization of GM-N explains the enhanced efficiency of GM, compared with FN, in supplying N to growing plants and increasing rice yields, N uptake, and N recovery. After a 3-wk post-rice fallow period, the top 60 cm of soil in the GM20 FN0 treatment contained 17 kg more mineral N ha-1 than the control (GM0 FN0) soil on 11 November (Fig. 2), presumably due to the mineralization of residual GM. These results suggest that mineralization of residual GM-N to the succeeding wheat crop reduced the fertilizer input by 25% for optimum wheat yield.

View larger version (46K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 2 Total amount of (a) NH4N and (b) NO3N in the 60-cm soil profile of no-N control (GM0 FN0FN0) and green manure (GM20 FN0FN0) treatment in a ricewheat cropping system during Year 2 (19931994). GM is green manure and FN is fertilizer N; subscripts denote application rates (Mg ha-1 and kg ha-1, respectively). *Indicates significant difference (P 0.05) between no-N control and green manure treatment. The periods under fallowing (F), rice, and wheat are marked on the x axis
|
|
Mineralization of soil organic N (including leftover crop stubbles) during the two fallow periods after harvest of rice (OctoberNovember) and wheat (AprilJune) was apparent from the accumulation of NO3N in soil. In Year 1, mineral N increased by 14 kg N ha-1 in the GM0 FN0FN0 soil, from 68 to 82 kg N ha-1 between 22 Oct. and 19 Nov. 1992 (data not shown). In Year 2, after the harvest of rice on 9 Oct. 1993, mineral N in the 0- to 60-cm soil profile of no-N plots increased by 16 kg N ha-1 from 59 to 75 kg N ha-1 between 19 Oct. and 11 Nov. 1993 (Fig. 2). Similarly, after wheat harvest on 10 Apr. 1993, mineral N in the no-N plots increased by 9 kg N ha-1 from 62 kg N ha-1 on 27 Apr. 1993 to 71 kg N ha-1 on 16 June 1993. These results illustrate that despite low organic matter of most subtropical soils, such as the one used in our study (3.8 g OC kg-1 soil), a modest amount of N can be supplied to produce crop grain and straw yields of 4 to 5 Mg ha-1 annually.
Effects of Rice and Wheat on Ammonium and Nitrate Distribution in the Soil Profile
The distributions of NO3N and NH4N in different soil layers changed frequently; however, changes in NH4N in subsurface layers (1530 and 3060 cm) were relatively small compared with those of NO3N (Fig. 1 and 2). For example, data after rice harvest of Year 2 presented in Table 7 illustrate that NO3N present in the 60-cm soil profile was significantly greater in GM0 FN120FN120 (39%), GM20 FN0FN0 (58%), GM20 FN90FN90 (67%), and GM40 FN120FN90 treatments (120%) than in GM0 FN0FN0. Further, the amount of NO3N remaining in different soil layers after rice harvest was 37 to 109% greater than after wheat harvest (Table 7). Rice, a shallow-rooted crop, primarily uses nutrients in the surface soil layer and allows NO3N to move deeper in the soil, where it is prone to loss via leaching to groundwater (Bajwa et al., 1993; Aulakh, 1994). However, significant amounts of the NO3N from all soil layers up to 60-cm depth were used by wheat following rice because of its deeper and more extensive rooting system that enables it to take up N from lower soil layers (Bijay-Singh and Sekhon, 1977). From these data, however, it is not possible to verify such effects of wheat beneath the 60-cm soil depth.
View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Table 7 Nitrate-N in different layers of the soil profile after the harvest of rice and wheat after 2 yr of the ricewheat crop rotation
|
|
In earlier studies with porous soils, substantial leaching of NO3N below the root zone was observed from fields under heavily fertilized shallow-rooted crops such as maize (Arora et al., 1980) and potato (Solanum tuberosum L.) (Bijay-Singh and Sekhon, 1977). Based on groundwater NO3N analysis of 236 samples collected from 21- to 38-m-deep tubewells located in different areas of Punjab state, Bajwa et al. (1993) observed that 17% of samples containing >5 mg NO3N L-1 were obtained from tubewells located in vegetable growing areas, as compared with only 3% of samples from regions where ricewheat rotation is practiced. The results of our study with a ricewheat system demonstrate that rooting patterns of crops can strongly influence NO3 accumulation in the soil profile, and wheat following rice could reduce the potential hazard of NO3 leaching to deeper soil layers and groundwater.
Leaching of Ammonium and Nitrate
The amount of NH4N and NO3N present in different layers of soil at the end of four cycles of a ricewheat rotation revealed that the different amounts of applied FN and incorporated GM did not affect NH4N content of the soil profile to 150 cm (data not shown) but resulted in significant differences in NO3N ranging from 59 to 101 kg N ha-1 (Table 8)
. Application of the recommended rate of 120 kg FN ha-1 to both rice and wheat (GM0 FN120FN120) in split applications for 4 yr resulted in a significant increase of 35 kg NO3N ha-1 greater than the no-N control, 74% of this increase occurred in the 90- to 150-cm soil depth. The increase of 16 kg NO3N ha-1 with the GM20 FN0FN0 and 19 kg NO3N ha-1 with the GM20 FN60FN90 treatment was not significant. However, incorporation of 40 Mg GM ha-1 in conjunction with 120 kg N ha-1 in rice (GM40 FN120FN90) resulted in a residual of 42 kg NO3N ha-1 greater than the control; 70% of this NO3N was located in the 90- to 150-cm soil layer, subject to leaching to deeper soil layers and subsequent NO3 contamination of groundwater. The wheat crop that followed rice in this treatment only received 90 kg FN ha-1, 75% of the recommended N rate, but produced dry matter, grain, and N yields that were similar to a wheat crop supplied with 120 kg FN ha-1 (Table 5). However, all NO3N reserves in the soil profile, especially in the 90- to 150-cm layer, were not removed by the wheat crop. Perhaps the amount of NO3N present in the soil profile was in excess of wheat crop needs or was moved beyond the active zone for nutrient absorption by roots. Because farmers tend to apply N in excess of crop requirements (Aulakh and Bijay-Singh, 1997), this could cause alarming groundwater contamination in some cases, as indicated by earlier reports (Singh et al., 1987; Singh, 1992). The results of this study clearly demonstrate that excess N applied through FN and GM reduces crop yields and results in leaching of NO3 to deeper soil layers. A major portion of enhanced soil NO3 (7074%) occurring in the 90- to 150-cm depth indicates the possibility of NO3 leaching below 150 cm and into groundwater. However, NO3N enrichment of the groundwater lifted by the tubewell located in the vicinity of the present experimental site, which was used for irrigation, remained uncontaminated. Groundwater NO3 levels should be closely watched in the future; if NO3 leaching occurs below 150 cm, groundwater might become a significant contributor to N fertilization of crops but be unfit for human and animal consumption.
View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Table 8 Nitrate-N in the soil profile before and after 4 yr of fertilizer N and green manure treatments in ricewheat rotation
|
|
 |
Conclusions and recommendations
|
|---|
Results of this 4-yr field study with an irrigated ricewheat system in a semiarid, subtropical soil low in organic C support several conclusions that may have useful agronomic and environmental implications. Our results indicate that supply of nutrients through the integrated use of 20 Mg GM and 60 kg FN ha-1 provides advantages over the use of FN alone, producing greater yields of rice and wheat while reducing the use of FN by >50% in rice and 25% in wheat. By adopting the use of GM alone, the farmer can attain rice yields comparable with those produced with the recommended fertilizer rate of 120 kg FN ha-1. Under aerobic soil conditions, accumulation of 9 to 16 kg N ha-1 mineral N in unfertilized control soils in a 4- to 8-wk fallow period demonstrated the modest capacity of such soils to supply sufficient N to produce crop grain and straw yields of 4 to 5 Mg ha-1 annually. Rapid movement of applied FN to lower soil depths suggests that mineral N determination in such soils would be most reliable when soil is sampled to a 60-cm depth instead of the current practice of only sampling to the 15- or 30-cm depths. Mineralization of green manure N was quite rapid and resulted in a similar or enhanced plant N-use efficiency than that obtained with FN. A strong influence of FN application, incorporation of GM, rooting pattern of crops, and anaerobic and upland soil conditions was evident on the dynamics and distribution patterns of NO3N in the soil profile and its potential for leaching beyond the root zone. The use of 20 Mg ha-1 of legume GM in conjunction with 60 kg FN ha-1 to achieve an optimum nutrient supply for rice could significantly reduce NO3 leaching in soil, providing environmental benefits in addition to agronomic effects. However, the use of excessive FN in conjunction with GM will reduce fertilizer-use efficiency, may lower crop yields due to lodging from excessive vegetative growth, and can result in substantial NO3 leaching below the rooting zone, increasing the potential for NO3 contamination of groundwater. This study demonstrated that the rooting pattern of crops exerts a profound influence in controlling NO3 distribution pattern and leaching in the soil profile. Therefore, shallow-rooted rice grown in rotation with wheat, which has a deeper and more extensive root system, appears a promising approach to efficiently use residual N and minimize leaching of NO3 to greater soil depths in irrigated porous soils.
 |
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
|
|---|
We gratefully acknowledge the financial assistance received from the Office of International Cooperation and Development, USDA, and the suggestions and critical review of an earlier version of this manuscript by Dr. Wally Wilhelm, USDA-ARS, University of Nebraska, Lincoln, NE; Dr. Changsheng. Li, University of New Hampshire, Durham, NH; and Dr. Kevin Bronson, Texas A&M University, Lubbock, TX.
Received for publication April 29, 1998.
 |
REFERENCES
|
|---|
- Anonymous Guidelines for collecting soil samples for soil testing. Ludhiana, Punjab, India: Soil Testing Laboratory, Dep. of Soils, Punjab Agricultural Univ, 1990.
- Arora, R.P., M.S. Sachdev, Y.K. Sud, V.K. Luthra, and B.V. Subbiah. 1980. Fate of fertilizer nitrogen in a multiple cropping system. p. 332. In Soil nitrogen as fertilizer or pollutant. Int. Atomic Energy Agency, Vienna.
- Aulakh, M.S. 1994. Integrated nitrogen management and leaching of nitrates to groundwater under cropping systems followed in tropical soils of India. p. 205221. In Trans. 15th World Cong. Soil Sci. Vol. 5a. Acapulco, Mexico. Int. Soc. of Soil Sci.
- Aulakh M.S., Bijay-Singh Nitrogen losses and fertilizer N use efficiency in irrigated porous soils. Nutr. Cycl. Agroecosyst. 1997;7:1-16.
- Aulakh M.S., Doran J.W., Mosier A.R. Soil denitrificationSignificance, measurement, and effects of management. Adv. Soil Sci. 1992;18:1-57.
- Aulakh M.S., Doran J.W., Walters D.T., Mosier A.R., Francis D.D. Crop residue type and placement effects on denitrification and mineralization. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 1991;55:1020-1025.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
- Aulakh M.S., Kuldip-Singh Bijay-Singh, Doran J.W. Kinetics of nitrification under upland and flooded soils of varying texture. Commun. Soil Sci. Plant Anal. 1996;27:2079-2089.
- Aulakh M.S., Pasricha N.S. Fertilizer nitrogen management and environment pollutionIndian scenario. In: Kanwar J.S., Katyal J.C., eds. Plant nutrient needs, supply, efficiency and policy issues: 20002025. New Delhi: Natl. Acad. of Agric. Sci, 1997:296-313 a.
- Aulakh M.S., Pasricha N.S. Effect of green manuring and fertilizer N application on enhancing crop productivity in mustardrice rotation in semiarid subtropical regions. Eur. J. Agron. 1997;8:51-58 b.
- Bartolome V.I., Casumpang R.M., Ynalvez M.A.H., Olea A.B., McLaren C.G. IRRISTAT for WindowsStatistical software for agricultural research. Los Baños, Philippines: Biometrics, IRRI, 1999.
- Bajwa, M.S., Bijay-Singh, and Parminder-Singh. 1993. Nitrate pollution of groundwater under different systems of land management in the Punjab. p. 223230. In First agricultural science congress1992. Natl. Acad. of Agric. Sci., New Delhi.
- Bijay-Singh, Sekhon G.S. Some measures of reducing leaching loss of nitrates beyond potential rooting zone. III. Proper crop rotation. Plant Soil 1977;47:585-591.
- Bijay-Singh, Yadvinder-Singh Green manuring and biological N fixation: North Indian perspective. In: Kanwar J.S., Katyal J.C., eds. Plant nutrient needs, supply, efficiency and policy issues: 20002025. New Delhi: Natl. Acad. of Agric. Sci, 1997:29-44.
- Bijay-Singh, Yadvinder-Singh, Sekhon G.S. Fertilizer-N use efficiency and nitrate pollution of groundnut in developing countries. J. Contam. Hydrol. 1995;20:167-184.
- Bouldin D.R., Klausner S.D., Reid W.S. Use of N from manure. In: Hauck R.D., ed. Nitrogen in crop production. Madison, WI: ASA, CSSA, and SSSA, 1984:221-245.
- Buresh R.J., De Datta S.K. Nitrogen dynamics and management in ricelegume cropping systems. Adv. Agron. 1991;45:1-59.
- Gill G.S. Package of practices for kharif (summer) and rabi (winter) crops. Ludhiana, Punjab, India: Directorate of Ext. Educ., Punjab Agricultural Univ, 1995.
- Gomez K.A., Gomez A.A. Statistical procedures for agricultural research, 2nd ed New York: John Wiley and Sons, 1976.
- IRRI. World rice statistics 1990. Los Baños, Philippines: IRRI, 1991.
- Khera T.S., Aulakh M.S., Doran J.W. Significance of soil depth on nitrogen transformations in flooded and nonflooded systems under laboratory conditions. Nutr. Cycl. Agroecosyst. 1999;54:209-213.
- Kuldip-Singh M.S., Aulakh Bijay-Singh, Doran J.W. Effect of soil pH on kinetics of nitrification in semiarid subtropical soils under upland and flooded conditions. J. Indian Soc. Soil Sci. 1996;44:378-381.
- Ladha J.K., Garrity D.P. Green manure production systems for Asian ricelands. Los Baños, Philippines: IRRI, 1994.
- Ladha J.K., Kundu D.K., Angelo-Van Coppenolle M.G., Peoples M.B., Carangal V.R., Dart P.J. Legume productivity and soil nitrogen dynamics in lowland rice-based cropping systems. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 1996;60:183-192.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
- Maskina M.S., Bijay-Singh, Yadvinder-Singh, Meelu O.P. Fertilizer requirement of ricewheat and maizewheat rotations on coarse-textured soils amended with farmyard manure. Fert. Res. 1988;17:153-164.
- Morris R.A., Furoc R.E., Dizon M.A. Rice responses to a short-duration green manure. II. N recovery and utilization. Agron. J. 1989;78:413-416.
- Mulvaney R.L. Nitrogeninorganic forms. In: Sparks D.L., ed. Methods of soil analysis. Part 3. Madison, WI: SSSA and ASA, 1996:1123-1184 SSSA Book Ser. 5..
- Olson R.J., Hensler R.E., Attoe O.J., Witzwl S.A., Peterson L.A. Fertilizer nitrogen and crop rotation in relation to movement of nitrate nitrogen through soil profiles. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. Proc. 1970;34:448-452.
- Sandhu B.S., Khera K.L., Prihar S.S., Baldev-Singh Irrigation needs and yield of rice on a sandy-loam soil as affected by continuous and intermittent submergence. Indian J. Agric. Sci. 1980;50:492-496.
- Singh I., Bijay-Singh, Bal H.S. Indiscriminate fertilizer use vis-a-vis groundwater pollution in central Punjab. Indian J. Agric. Econ. 1987;42:404-409.
- Singh P. Nitrates in the soil profiles and ground waters under different systems of land use in the Punjab. Ludhiana, Punjab, India: Punjab Agric. Univ, 1992 M.Sc. thesis..
- Spalding R.F., Kitchen L.A. Nitrate in the intermediate vadose zone beneath irrigated cropland. Ground Water Monit. Rev. 1988;8:89-95.
- USEPA. Nitrate/nitrite health advisory (draft). Washington, DC: USEPA, Office of Drinking Water, 1985.
- Walters D.T., Aulakh M.S., Doran J.W. Effects of soil aeration, legume residue and soil texture on transformations of macro and micronutrients in soils. Soil Sci. 1992;153:100-107.
- Westerman R.L. Soil testing and plant analysis, 3rd ed Madison, WI: SSSA, 1990 SSSA Book Ser. 3..
- Yadvinder-Singh, Bijay-Singh, Maskina M.S., Meelu O.P. Effect of organic manures, crop residues and green manure (Sesbania aculeata) on nitrogen and phosphorus transformation in a sandy loam soil at field capacity and under waterlogged conditions. Biol. Fertil. Soils 1988;6:183-187.
- Yadvinder-Singh, Bijay-Singh, Maskina M.S., Meelu O.P. Response of wetland rice to nitrogen from cattle manure and urea in a ricewheat rotation. Trop. Agric. (Trinidad) 1995;72:91-96.
This article has been cited by other articles:

|
 |

|
 |
 
C. M. Cherr, J. M. S. Scholberg, and R. McSorley
Green Manure Approaches to Crop Production: A Synthesis
Agron. J.,
February 7, 2006;
98(2):
302 - 319.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
M. S. Aulakh, T.S. Khera, J. W. Doran, and K. F. Bronson
Managing Crop Residue with Green Manure, Urea, and Tillage in a Rice-Wheat Rotation
Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J.,
May 1, 2001;
65(3):
820 - 827.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|