|
|
||||||||
a Dep. of Agronomy, Kansas State Univ., Manhattan, KS 66506
b 3121 Miller Plant Sciences Bldg., University of Georgia, Athens, GA 30606
c Kansas State University, 2004 Throckmorton Plant Sciences Center, Dep. of Agronomy, Manhattan, KS 66506-5501
* Corresponding author (cwrice{at}ksu.edu).
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Abbreviations: AC, ambient CO2 with chamber Cnew, new carbon EC, elevated CO2 with chamber MRT, mean residence time NC, ambient CO2 no chamber PMC, potentially mineralizable C PMN, potentially mineralizable N SOM, soil organic matter
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Many studies show no effect of elevated CO2 on soil or total ecosystem C (Oechel et al., 1994; Luo et al., 1996; Hungate et al., 1997; Van Kessel et al., 2000). Other studies report evidence of soil C sequestration (Leavitt et al., 1994; Wood et al., 1994; Williams et al., 2000), or provide evidence that more C is sequestered into other ecosystem components, such as plant biomass (Tissue et al., 1997). Since most of the studies were typically 4 yr or less in duration, the potential for long-term sequestration would be difficult to detect. Furthermore, different ecosystems are limited or controlled by a variety of factors, so that understanding why certain ecosystems respond and others do not will become important for understanding the potential for C sequestration under elevated CO2.
Most of the C deposited into soil will be decomposed and respired as CO2, but some of it will eventually become chemically and physically recalcitrant (Paul and Clark, 1996; Stevenson and Cole, 1999). In the three-pool model of SOM, active and microbial C and N are used synonymously as a fraction that is inherently decomposable and more vulnerable to decomposition when environmental conditions, such as temperature and water availability, are favorable. The passive soil fraction is defined as having mean residence times (MRTs) of centuries to millennia; the slow pool is intermediate between the active and passive pools with an MRT measured in decades (Paul, 1984). How the size of different organic matter pools could be altered will provide information on the capacity of soils to store C as a consequence of elevated CO2.
Soil organic matter can be conceptually defined as a series of fractions that comprise a continuum based on decomposition rate (Sanford and Smith, 1972; Paul and Clark, 1996). Long-term mineralization (250500 d) studies have been used to estimate the active and slow fraction of C and N in soil (Juma and Paul, 1984) and have shown promise for predicting available plant and crop nutrients in soil (Stanford and Smith, 1972; Rice and Havlin, 1994). Typically the slow fraction is composed of 5 to 40% of the SOM pool, and is relatively easy to define based on kinetic parameters obtained during the incubation (Stanford and Smith, 1972). The C and N left in soil after incubation is considered biologically more recalcitrant. Furthermore, separating the PMC and PMN from the more recalcitrant SOM can increase the power of analysis to detect changes in soil C and N (Cambardella and Elliot, 1992; Leavitt et al., 1996).
Though we do not know the exact
13C signature of the CO2 used to double the CO2 concentration from year to year, data presented in this paper, and from several other years suggests depleted
13C occurred from 1992 through 1995 (J. Jastrow, personal communication, 2001). This
13C altered the plant
13C signature of the plants, and the subsequent inputs of C to the soil. Since C4 grasses constitute the majority of net primary productivity (NPP) in tallgrass prairie (Freeman, 1998), the C3 plant contribution to the
13C signature was expected to be minimal. Changes in plant species composition over the 8-yr experiment were minor (Owensby et al., 1999).
Our objectives were to measure changes in the so-called active, slow, and passive pools by measuring microbial, potentially mineralizable, and residual soil C and N to evaluate the stability of new C under elevated CO2. We expected that the majority of soil C inputs under elevated CO2 (Williams et al., 2000) would occur in the potentially mineralizable pools of C and N. The 13C signal derived from elevated CO2 would reside primarily in the potentially mineralizable slow fraction, whereas smaller alterations, if detectable, would occur in the passive fraction.
| MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Treatments
Circular open-top chambers (4.5 m in diam.) were established in the field in early May 1989. Treatments were ambient CO2no chamber (NC), ambient CO2chamber (AC), and two times ambient CO2chamber (EC). Each treatment was replicated three times using a randomized complete block design. Carbon dioxide and air mixtures were supplied constantly from early April to late October. The overall experimental design is explained in detail by Owensby et al. (1993).
Laboratory Experiments
Soil was collected in August (0 to 5 cm) and October (5 to 15 cm) of 1996. Approximately 20 samples of soil (0- to 5-cm depth) were randomly collected from within the experimental plots using a 1.5-cm diam. soil core. Soil from the 5- to 15-cm depth was derived from 25-cm diam. polyvinyl chloride (PVC) cores inserted into the whole plots in April 1996 and utilized for an isotope tracer study (Williams et al., 2001). Because of this, we will make our comparisons between treatments, and will not compare differences due to depth.
To aid removal of large roots and homogenize the soil, all samples were sieved to pass a 4-mm mesh. Soil samples (25 g) were added to 980-mL mason jars and were analyzed for microbial biomass C using the fumigationincubation procedure of Jenkinson and Powlson (1976). The mass of microbial biomass C was estimated using a kc of 0.41, as suggest by Voroney and Paul (1984). Assuming that the fumigated and unfumigated samples represent their respective pools and are homogeneously mixed, we calculated
13C of microbial C using the following equation:
![]() | [1] |
Fum represents the
13CO2 of the C respired from a fumigated sample,
Unfum represents the
13CO2 of the C respired from an unfumigated sample, and PUnfum represents the proportion of C in the unfumigated compared with the fumigated sample. The
13C content of the CO2 of the fumigated and unfumigated controls were measured on a continuous flow Europa 20/20 Isotope Ratio Mass Spectrometer (Europa, Crewe, UK) using a purge needle attached to an autosampler at a flow rate of 80 mL min1. The gas sample containing the CO2 was first passed through a water trap containing Mg(ClO4)2, and then further separated and purified using a Porapak Q (Alltech Assoc., Inc., Deerfield, IL) (0.318 cm by 2 m; 80100 mesh) column (25°C) before introduction into the mass spectrometer. Gas samples were tested periodically for high levels of N2O using an 63Ni electron capture detector with a similar Porapak Q column. All samples contained from 28 to 80 µg C per 10 mL injection. Two jars without soil were also used to account for background levels of CO2. Background levels were between 410 to 490 µL CO2 L1. We were not equipped to accurately measure the isotopic signature of these low concentrations by isotope ratio mass spectrometry (IRMS), so we assumed that the
13C-Vienna PeeDee Belemnite (VPDB) of the CO2 was 8. Total analytical precision for the isotopic composition of CO2 was 0.31
when using a standardized calcium carbonate mixture, which was converted to CO2 using freshly prepared and degassed 1 M acetic acid. Calcium carbonate was standardized relative to National Bureau of Standards (NBS)-19 in both solid and gaseous forms, and stored with a water trap in an airtight desiccator.
Potentially mineralizable C and PMN incubations lasted up to 422 d, but all data could be fitted to a one-pool model (Stanford and Smith, 1972) by Day 290. Three PVC cores (5.08 cm diam., 10 cm height) per replicate plot were packed with field-moist sieved soil (approximately 100 g d.w.) and packed to a bulk density of 1 g cm3. Cores were preleached with eight separate additions of a 50-mL solution of 0.01 M CaCl2 by placing the cores on a plastic buchner funnel sealed to a side-arm Erlenmeyer flask connected to a vacuum pump (0.033 MPa). The funnel contained a sealed cellulose filter (Millipore Corp., Bedford, MA) with a bubble point pressure of 0.0685 MPa and was filled with an approximately 25-mm thick bed of glass beads (29-µm mean particle size, Potters Industries, Inc., Parisppany, NJ). Approximately 1 h after the last CaCl2 addition, the solution was weighed and a portion was poured into scintillation vials to prepare for inorganic N (NH+4 and NO3) measurement, then 50 mL of a free solution was added to each core. Calcium chloride extracts were analyzed colorimetrically for NH+4 and NO3 contents on an Alpkem Autoanalyzer (Alpkem Corp., Clackamas, OR). Ammonium N was determined by the salicylate-hypochlorite method (Crooke and Simpson, 1971) and NO3 + NO2N by the Griess-IIosvay technique (Keeney and Nelson, 1982). Carbon dioxide was measured periodically to assess PMC, but also to maintain O2 levels above 19% in the incubation jars containing the soil. Details of the procedure used to estimate PMC and PMN are outlined in Omay et al. (1997). Respired CO2 and its
13C signature were measured periodically as previously described. Gaps in the 13C data (Fig. 1)
between 185 and 295 d of incubation were a result of problems with the IRMS. Carbon dioxide and inorganic N data from each replicate core were fitted to the one pool model and then averaged to represent the mean amount of potentially mineralizable C and N for that replicate plot.
|
13C were determined by dry combustion of 15 mg samples derived from soil previously sieved and meticulously cleaned of root material (dried and ground with mortar and pestle) and determined on the IRMS. Root
13C (with few or no rhizomes) was estimated from samples collected at the end of the 1995 growing season. Samples were ground and passed through a 250-µm sieve before weighing 1 mg for
13C analysis. New root growth was sampled using in-growth cores described by Owensby et al. (1999). Soil pH was 6.6 to 6.8, and CaCO3 was absent, so no acid pretreatment to remove inorganic C was necessary.
Biologically recalcitrant (passive) C and N were determined by subtracting the mass of PMC and PMN from the total soil C and N, respectively. To estimate if some of the Cnew was present into the recalcitrant pools we applied a calculated and a measured method. The measured method simply utilized the
13C values of the soil before and after the 290-d incubation. The
13CO2 data was only available for the first 150-d of incubation at the 0- to 5-cm depth. The calculated method was estimated with the following equation:
![]() | [2] |
r was the
13C value of the recalcitrant soil pool, Mt was the mass of total C,
t is the
13C value of the total soil pool, Mi was the mass of CO2C produced during each incubation interval, and
i was
13C value at each incubation interval. An incubation interval was defined as the number of days between
13C measurements (Fig. 1). The mass of C and
13C for each interval was taken as the midpoint (or average) between the two data points. It was considered that some of the Cnew found in the recalcitrant pool may have been transferred from the potentially mineralizable pool, and this possibility is further communicated in the discussion. Data were analyzed separately and conjointly by Proc Mixed (SAS Institute, 1996). Assumptions for normality were assessed, and all data presented met normality criteria. The model class statements were replication, treatment, and depth. The least significant difference (LSD) mean separation tests were used to determine where significant differences occurred. All results were considered significantly different at P < 0.10.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
13C values were significantly decreased in EC and NC relative to AC at the 0- to 5-cm depth, and significantly decreased in EC relative to AC and NC at the 5- to 15-cm depth (Table 2). At both depths, estimates of passive soil
13C were very similar to total soil
13C, but with a 0.7 to 0.8
enrichment. At the 5- to 15-cm depth measured and calculated recalcitrant soil
13C values were similar, but treatment differences were detected only with the calculated values. Microbial biomass (start of incubation) and root
13C were significantly depleted in EC relative to AC and NC at both the 0- to 5- and 5- to 15-cm depths (Table 2). These
13C values are very similar within each treatment and depth, except for the EC treatment at 5- to 15-cm depth. At the end of the laboratory incubation (5- to 15-cm depth) the microbial biomass
13C was significantly enriched compared with the start of the incubation, particularly true with CO2 enrichment.
|
During long-term incubation respired
13C-CO2 was slightly depleted in EC relative to AC and NC (0- to 5-cm depth) throughout most of the 150-d incubation (Fig. 1a). At the 5- to 15-cm depth, the
13C-CO2 respired was significantly depleted in EC relative to AC and NC until Day 301 (Fig. 1b). After Day 301, differences in
13C among treatments only occurred at Day 377. Before incubation (5- to 15-cm depth), approximately 70% of the new C in the PMC pool could be accounted for by microbial biomass.
Total amount of passive soil C was not significantly different among treatments at either depth (Table 3). Passive soil N was enhanced at the 5- to 15-cm depth in EC compared with AC and NC, but no differences were detected at the 0- to 5-cm depth.
|
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Microbial activity is related to decomposition rates in soil, and during a typical tallgrass prairie-growing season, greater water contents generally translate into enhanced rates of microbial activity (Williams et al., 2000). Williams et al. (2000) showed a strong positive relationship between greater soil water and microbial activity in elevated compared with ambient conditions. But apparently, increases in plant inputs have outpaced increases in decomposition rates. A reduction in soil temperature is a factor that might contribute to C accrual in the PMC fraction.
No change in potentially mineralizable N was found at the 5- to 15-cm depth, but both elevated CO2 and chambers significantly influenced PMN stocks in the surface 5-cm. This result suggests that chambers cause a reduction in PMN at the 0- to 5-cm depth, while elevated CO2 can partially offset this loss (Table 1). Yet, CO2 enrichment resulted in greater recalcitrant N but not greater PMN at the 5- to 15-cm depth, suggesting movement of N from the slow pool to a less easily mineralizable passive form. It is at the 5- to 15-cm depth that we see differences due to CO2 enrichment in both total and PMC.
From the perspective of potential ecosystem N losses, typical annual rates (Blair et al., 1998; Williams, 1998; Sotomayor, 1996) of denitrification, associative N-fixation, and NH3 volatilization from tallgrass prairie all range between 1 and 2 Kg N ha1 yr1. The difference in N content between EC and AC at the 5- to 15-cm depth was approximately 200 Kg N ha1. Only a small proportion of the greater soil N can be accounted for by changes in ecosystem N flux. Relatively large increases in N2fixation synchronized with dramatic reductions in denitrification and NH3 volatilization can at best, account for 10% of the greater soil N derived from CO2 enrichment under rates estimated under ambient conditions. It is unknown what effect enhanced C could have on these processes, although N fixation would be the most likely process affected by enhanced C availability.
If flux rates cannot account for the altered N pools, internal cycling within the prairie ecosystem might explain the dramatic change in soil N. Greater N stocks due to CO2 enrichment might be partly explained by the high degree of N limitation in the tallgrass prairie, and mechanisms that prairie plants utilize to cope with low levels of available N. Williams et al. (2001) conducted an experiment to test whether plants and soil microorganisms altered their stocks of an added 15N tracer as a result of CO2 enrichment. That study suggested that plant-microbial competition was enhanced because of CO2 enrichment, and that microorganisms may have reduced plant available N in the soil surface. As a result of this reduction in available N, plants may alter root architecture that favors subsurface root growth and exploration for N in elevated compared with ambient CO2 (Owensby et al., 1999). Greater N translocated to aboveground biomass from deeper soil depths could ultimately be stored in roots and rhizomes near the soil surface, and would eventually turnover and become a part of the surface soil N pool. Up to 40 Kg N ha1 yr1 is mineralized from organic sources in the top 15-cm of soil during a typical growing season (Blair, 1997) and plants assimilate a similar amount of N.
With the available data, we can provide only indirect explanations of how CO2 enrichment could foster an increase in soil N. The high degree of N limitation inherent in tallgrass prairie (Owensby et al., 1999) could be further exacerbated because of greater microbial N immobilization. Greater immobilization is driven by the increased root C inputs, and suggests that C availability appears to be driving the dynamics of soil N.
Though we cannot make quantitative assessments of C flow from roots to soil pools, a qualitative assessment indicates that relatively depleted
13C in the whole soil of the elevated CO2 treatment implies the presence of recently (<8yr) deposited new soil C (Cnew). Relatively depleted CO2 was supplied through a portion of the experiment as indicated by clippings of green leaf tissue at various intervals throughout the experiment. In elevated CO2, root biomass collected during 1996 was depleted 7 to 8
compared with ambient conditions. Because root inputs provide a large portion of C supplied to soil microorganisms, it was expected that microbial biomass
13C values should closely resemble those found in roots. This was the case in the surface 5-cm of soil and for the two ambient treatments at the 5- to 15-cm depth. Relatively undepleted microbial
13C found in the elevated CO2 treatment at the 5- to 15-cm depth suggests either slow turnover of C derived from roots or in a consistent source of 13C throughout the experiment. Some of the microbial C could be derived from older soil C, but the large degree of difference between the
13C of roots and microbial biomass would suggest that older soil C sources were not the primary contributor to the
13C of the microbial biomass. That is, for our value of microbial
13C, it would take a large amount of C flow from older more resistant soil pools in addition to a reduction in C flow from roots to the microbial biomass.
The difference in
13C of the CO2 evolved from the PMC fraction was relatively consistent throughout the 290-d incubation. Yet, the CO2 evolved during the incubation only differed in the elevated compared with the ambient CO2chambers by 1.5 to 2.5
at both the 0- to 5- (data not shown), and 5- to 15- cm depths (Fig. 1). This suggests either variation in
13C label during the 8-yr experiment or mineralization of older C sources during the laboratory incubation. During sample preparation for incubation the soil was sieved and homogenized, which may provide microorganisms with access to physically protected older soil C and thus relatively enriched
13C.
We attempted to measure a passive fraction of soil
13C by subtraction of PMC from the whole soil using a calculated (Eq. [2]) and measured methodology (Table 2). Though both sets of data closely resemble one another, only the calculated data indicate that a significant amount of Cnew resides in the passive fraction. Both of these two estimates nevertheless indicate that most of the new C resides in the passive fraction of the whole soil. Assuming that our methods truly represent various SOM fractions, the amount of new C residing in the passive relative to the slow fraction appears considerably higher than expected for a pool with a MRT of centuries to millennia. This is particularly true given the 7 to 8
difference in
13C of the new root input measured during the final year of the experiment. The most likely mechanisms for this new C incorporation into the passive soil fraction is derived from a relatively high rate of turnover and C flow from plant roots in situ, redistribution and occlusion during sieving, or a combination of the two influences. In contrast with the isotopic data, measurement of PMC suggest that most of the increase in C due to CO2 enrichment resides in the slow not the passive SOM pool.
The 60% increase in root growth during the 8-yr study was the likely catalyst for the greater potentially mineralizable soil C pools in the enriched CO2 treatment. Though PMC is an active fraction and its size is prone to changes in environmental conditions, it confirms that C can accrue in soils under elevated CO2. Our study suggests that C accrual into the relatively slow pool is possible due to elevated CO2. We can only hypothesize the mechanism of greater soil N that occurs with CO2 enrichment, and with current estimates of ecosystem N flux, we can explain just a small proportion the increase in soil N. Nitrogen accrual might be best explained through a mechanism of redistribution whereby soil N in roots is moved from the subsurface to surface because of enhanced N plant demand and enhanced associative N fixation. The increase in size of various soil N pools does indicate that N dynamics may be fundamentally altered in concert with, or directly due to C accrual. The total amount of new C increased under elevated CO2 was 4 Mg C ha1 over the 8-yr period for an annual rate of change of 0.5 Mg ha1 yr1.
Received for publication July 9, 2001.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| The SCI Journals | Agronomy Journal | Crop Science | |||
| Vadose Zone Journal | Journal of Plant Registrations | ||||
| Journal of Natural Resources and Life Sciences Education |
Journal of Environmental Quality |
||||